Why do gutters clog so badly in the hills?
Trees drop needles, leaves and cones into the gutters all year, and the wet debris packs into the lower runs. A clog holds water against the fascia and forces it over the front edge. The problem is worst after a windy week, when the debris is thickest.
Conifer needles are small and slippery, and they mat together in a gutter with leaves and bark. The matted layer holds water instead of letting it drain to the downspout, so the gutter fills from the bottom and overflows at its lowest seam. Pine and fir debris is especially good at blocking a downspout elbow.
A gutter that overflows at night can soak a wall before anyone sees it. The water runs behind siding and gutter straps, and the framing near the eave stays damp long after the rain has stopped. A homeowner who cleans the gutters twice a year may still miss the packed section in the lower run.
How much rain does this area see, and what does it mean for a roof?
The Santa Cruz Mountains average more than 50 inches of rain a year, according to the National Weather Service. A roof above that rainfall carries far more water than one on the flat, and the gutters and downspouts have to keep up.
Wet years in the hills can be far wetter than average. Ben Lomond has logged about 86 inches of rain in one very wet water year, and Boulder Creek has recorded about 76 inches in a year of the same kind. The records for these towns go back to 1937, and in a wet season the eaves and gutters see that rain day after day.
A roof that handled a dry winter well may fail in a wet one. The shingles, the flashing and the sealant age under the same rain, and a small weakness that stayed dry in one year can let water in during the next. Regular checks of the roof edge and the gutters before the rain starts are the cheapest protection the homeowner has.
Why does water show up in the room below the roof?
Water follows the framing down. It runs along rafters, sheathing and the tops of walls until it finds a gap, which is often far from where it entered. The ceiling stain marks where the water finally got through, not where the roof failed.
A roof is a sloped surface sitting over a flat ceiling, with a gap between the two that holds insulation, wires and ductwork. Water that gets through the roof covering lands on the sheathing, moves downhill along the rafter and finds the nearest opening, which may be a light box or the top of a partition wall.
This is why a patch on the roof does not always stop the stain on the ceiling. Wet insulation keeps releasing moisture into the room for days, and the framing stays damp behind the drywall. The drying has to follow the path, not the stain, or the ceiling will show the same mark again after the next rain.
What can a homeowner do before the rain starts?
Clean the gutters and the downspouts, check the roof edge for lifted shingles and loose flashing, and make sure the downspouts carry water well away from the foundation. Photograph the roof edge and the gutters so you have a record of their condition.
Clear the gutters from a ladder that is set on firm ground, and never work on a steep or wet roof. A garden hose run through each downspout shows whether the run is clear and whether the water reaches the ground. Replace any section that sags or pulls away from the fascia.
Look at the roof from the ground with binoculars for cracked shingles, bare patches and any flashing that lifts. Note the interior rooms under the roof and check the ceilings for faint marks. A small change caught early is usually a small job, and a roofer can close it before the next storm.
Does a roofer or the crew come first?
A roofer closes the opening, often with a tarp until the weather clears. The crew removes the wet material inside and dries the structure. The two jobs run side by side, and each needs the other's photographs and notes.
When water is still coming in, the roofer's tarp or repair stops the flow and the crew can work in the room without rain pouring through the ceiling. Neither job should wait for the other to finish, since wet insulation and ceiling board begin to fail within a day or two of soaking.
The crew does not repair the roof itself. It leaves a log of the wet areas, the readings that closed each one and the photographs of the framing, so the roofer knows what was damaged and where. That shared record keeps the repair from being aimed at the wrong place.